It’s Friday night, eight pm, working week finished, dinner done, postprandial port poured and passed to the left. My phone ‘bings’ and I’m curious to know which friend has posted on facebook. I check and see it is a fellow student and my heart sinks. They are posting about their assignment and would like help. I can’t ignore them, I’ve been there myself. I can’t turn off notifications as I enjoy interactions with my ‘real’ online friends. My head is once more full of all the things I ‘should’ be doing. Friday night is ruined.
The use of social media as a learning tool for students or teachers participating in professional development (PLD) blurs boundaries between different areas of life. In this blog I consider social media to be software that allows you to engage with others that you have chosen, with no set purpose. In this way I differentiate between online forums on specific subjects with specialised threads (and sometimes off topic threads) and formal online learning environments such as moodle, google and microsoft classrooms.
For social media to be used as a learning tool requires someone to act as facilitator and moderator in a similar way to forums and online classrooms. Without this the social media sites “might lack critical voices creating an echo chamber effect. The conversation may be too superficial in content knowledge or process to impact on ingrained practice and tacit capabilities.” (Melhuish, K.2013).
The tone and content of an online discussion also impact on the quality of the experience. Snowden states in her article “I’m right and you’re wrong” the ability to engage in online discussion has revealed an “appalling lack of civility”. As teachers we have a duty to protect our students but a closed social media group quickly becomes a classroom forum and not a true social media experience. Snowden goes on to say “nonsense and profundity, truth and fabrication, have equal rights on social media. It can be a frustrating and bewildering place, and a great waster of time.”
This brings me to filtering aspects of social media. One layer of filtering can be applied by a moderator and another by the individual. Any form of filtering by the moderator keeps the subject on track but removes “the autonomy of individuals to construct and develop their own understanding in collaboration with others” (Anderson, 2005; Wenger, 1998 as cited by Melhuish, K.2013). The individual developing their own understanding is required to “locate information, filter its value, and make rational and meaningful connections across bodies of information.” (Melhuish, K.2013).
On social media, as in other places, there is a tendency for confirmation bias to creep in. Even for me as I write this blog. A stance is taken and then proven. A technique to balance this was developed by Lord, Lepper and Preston (1984) in a study called “Considering the Opposite” and one I have used to counter personal, unconscious bias.
And herein lies the potential value of social media as a learning tool. Unfiltered it allows individuals to practise the skills of critical thinking and develop “the capacity to form connections between sources of information, and thereby create useful information patterns, is required to learn in our knowledge economy.” (Siemens 2004/5). Coupled with loud, angry debate and deliberate provocative lies social media may well be the tool to grow resilient and critically informed citizens.
But my NCEA students are tested on their knowledge of the properties of materials and how to make furniture. They will google and research. They will not ask the opinion of the masses. I will not interrupt their Friday nights with random posts about jointing techniques. They, and I, should have the option to choose when to engage.
Blending all aspects of my life is not for me. I shall keep social as social, forums for personal interests, and enrol on online courses for PLD.
In response to a ‘bing’ on my phone I wrote this blog. But that’s okay; it is my assignment. Now where is that port?
References and influences in the order they appear:
Melhuish, K. (2013) Online social networking and its impact on New Zealand educators’ professional learning. Sections 4.4 retrieved from
Snowden C. (2016) I’m right and you’re wrong retrieved from:
Anderson, T. (2005). Distance learning: Social software’s killer app? ODLAA 2005 Conference. Presented at the ODLAA 2005 Conference, online. Retrieved from
Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Lord C G, Lepper M, Preston E 1984 Considering the Opposite retrieved from http://synapse.princeton.edu/~sam/lord_lepper_preston84_JPSP_considering-the-opposite.pdf.
Siemens, G. (2004, December 12, Updated April 5 2005). Connectivism: A learning theory for the digital age. elearnspace. Retrieved from http://www.elearnspace.org/Articles/connectivism.htm
No comments:
Post a Comment